NEW YORK — Clifton Truman Daniel was in first grade when he found one thing shocking about his grandpa. When the trainer requested every scholar to introduce themselves and share slightly bit about their household, Daniel stood up, mentioned his identify, and sat again down. Then the trainer requested, “Wasn’t your grandfather president of america?”
This was news to Daniel, who went house that day and marched throughout the lounge. “Mother, do you know that Grandpa Truman had been president?” he mentioned. As Daniel recalled, his mom rolled her eyes and mentioned, “Sure, sure. However bear in mind one thing: Any little boy’s grandfather might be president. Don’t let it go to your head.”
The next yr, Daniel and his dad and mom represented the Truman household at President Lyndon Johnson’s 1965 inauguration, and have been invited to a personal breakfast on the White Home. Time handed; his father checked out his watch and introduced, “We’ve a practice to catch.” “Chill out,” mentioned the president. “You’ve obtained time.”
Lastly, the household rushed to a ready automotive, then have been whisked to Union Station, the place they sprinted down the practice platform. “Of us, decelerate, decelerate,” a conductor informed them. “The White Home known as.” And that’s when the 7-year-old boy lastly obtained it: “Oh my God. My grandfather may cease trains.”
Now Daniel, 64, serves because the vp of the brand new Society of Presidential Descendants. Nineteen different White Home scions — from the sixth-great granddaughters of James Monroe to the grandson of Jimmy Carter — gathered with their friends at Manhattan’s College Membership for the group’s inaugural dinner final weekend. For a lot of, it was the primary time assembly one another and an opportunity to check notes on what it means to be certainly one of solely 46 households with a president within the household tree.
“We name them the Eisenhower years, the Kennedy years, the Johnson years,” mentioned presidential historian Douglas Brinkley, who served as emcee for the night time. “Presidents matter. We run our historic timeline in america round presidential elections. In a star tradition, presidents are the highest of the meals chain.”
For some descendants, that’s a supply of delight and delight. For others, it’s a burden. For many, it’s a accountability that defines them in methods each huge and small.
“I’m within the individuals who have preceded me and the way they lived,” mentioned Lynda Johnson Robb, 77, the oldest daughter of Lyndon Johnson, when requested about this new group. Robb is a vp of the group and the one youngster of a president to this point to hitch; most first little children can’t look forward to the day they will escape the highlight and concentrate on their very own lives.
“They’re actual individuals,” she added. “They stroll and speak and cry moist tears.”
Tweed Roosevelt, a great-grandson of Theodore Roosevelt, and Massee McKinley, a great-great grandson of Grover Cleveland and great-great nephew of William McKinley, met three years in the past at a White Home Historic Affiliation occasion in Washington, D.C. The 2 males hit it off and determined there wanted to be a nationwide group for presidential descendants — initially as a approach for households to satisfy, after which as a discussion board for presidential scholarship and civic engagement. Sometimes, presidential households have their very own associations and reunions, however there wasn’t one group devoted to bringing collectively all of the households.
The nonpartisan group is invitation-only however inclusive; descendants of presidential siblings additionally rely. The pandemic postponed many of the plans till this yr, and not one of the best-known fashionable households — Kennedys, Clintons or Obamas — have joined to this point. (The board has not but prolonged an invite to the Trumps.)
And, to be sincere, not each descendant desires to spend time speaking about their well-known ancestor. However if you happen to’re a McKinley or a Roosevelt — properly, it’s often one of many first questions individuals ask.
The Roosevelt identify wasn’t a giant deal at boarding faculty, however at Harvard, Tweed was admonished for breaking the costume code: “Mr. Roosevelt, it’s all proper for the opposite children to do this, however it’s not all best for you.”
“My first thought was, properly, this isn’t honest,” he recalled. “And that’s once I realized that the advantages I get by being a Roosevelt comes with accountability — and one of many tasks is the general public face you placed on and that different individuals get pleasure out of assembly you and are inquisitive about your kinfolk.” All people desires to the touch the presidency. “So we’re form of a surrogate for that, and this generally is a downside.”
When he was younger, individuals would inform Roosevelt they have been so honored to satisfy him, however he rapidly realized none of it was truly about him. “The myths about TR are largely true — there’s no approach I can do what he did. I wouldn’t discuss it, however it’s fairly intimidating to have such a larger-than-life ancestor.”
Now 79, his job is usually simply to pay attention: to the tales individuals find out about Teddy or his distant cousin Franklin Delano, or ideas on a favourite quote or speech. “One of many burdens is it’s a must to pay attention politely and faux you’ve by no means heard the story.”
And this: Individuals would inform him their grandfather or great-grandfather was a Tough Rider — a member of the well-known cavalry unit that fought alongside Theodore Roosevelt throughout the Spanish-American Conflict. Tweed Roosevelt quickly discovered that anybody who fought in that conflict was a Tough Rider, not less than in accordance with household lore.
“Once I was younger, I’d pop that balloon,” he defined. “After which I mentioned to myself, ‘You already know, why try this? So I then switched to ‘I’m glad to listen to it. That’s great.’ Once I obtained older, I spotted I ought to pay extra consideration to the individual I’m speaking to and simply make them really feel good.”
Many descendants battle to stability historic information with standard narratives.
McKinley, 48, knew he was descended from two presidents when he was 7 or 8; his father was a historical past trainer. Rising up, individuals assumed he can be a politician or concerned in authorities. “I’ve by no means seen myself as being somebody that aspired to that, and so I’d by no means actually reside as much as that legacy,” he mentioned. However he does really feel a accountability to ensure that Cleveland and McKinley are given their due.
The issue, after all, is that most individuals don’t know a lot about both president. In order that they discuss McKinley’s assassination or they discuss Mount McKinley, which turns into a dialogue about Alaska and whether or not he’s mad they modified the identify to Denali. (He’s not.)
On the finish of the day, being a descendant means giving individuals the chance to speak about what it means for them to be an American. And to see presidents of their full humanity — one thing the brand new group hopes to emphasise. Mentioned McKinley, “We attempt to deliver collectively individuals from each events and talk about all of the presidencies: the great, the unhealthy, the ugly.”
The nice: Patricia Taft loves being the great-granddaughter of William Howard Taft, and comes from a household filled with Ohio politicians.
“Rising up a Taft, I I simply all the time felt like I may very well be like an envoy for the presidency or america,” she mentioned.
She reeled off some Taft trivia: “He was the primary president to do something that was lifestyle-oriented in public: He was the primary to golf publicly, which is slightly random however nobody did that earlier than him. He was the primary to throw out the pitch on the baseball recreation. He was the primary president additionally to have his funeral broadcast on the radio.”
Only for the report: The story about Taft getting caught in a tub? There’s no proof it’s true, and “let’s be sincere, I additionally really feel like Taft has gotten a foul rap.”
Patricia, 36, needed to be on the dinner final weekend however missed it due to one other descendant: Her new child daughter, whom she named Herron after Taft’s spouse, Helen Herron Taft.
The unhealthy: For the primary 15 years of his life, Ulysses Grant Dietz prevented his first identify. The nice-great-grandson of the Civil Conflict common and president was given the ancestral moniker however known as Grant by his dad and mom as a result of the president had develop into an object of ridicule, due to the rise of the pro-Confederacy mythology generally known as the Misplaced Trigger. “With a view to make Robert E. Lee a hero, Ulysses Grant needed to develop into a villain,” mentioned Dietz.
As a teen, he determined to reclaim his actual first identify. “When it turned recognized to those who I used to be descended from Ulysses, the very first thing they’d do was make enjoyable of him: He was a drunk. He was a butcher. He was a foul president. He was a silly scholar. None of which have been true, truly,” mentioned Dietz, 66. “However consequently, I didn’t actually put myself on the market.”
In his 30s, Dietz was the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit towards the Inside Division for neglecting Grant’s Tomb in New York Metropolis. That led to a restoration — and Dietz’s personal deep dive into Grant scholarship, leading to a mission to provide the 18th president a good listening to: “I wish to set the report straight as a result of most of what’s been printed is fake.”
“I feel what’s occurred within the final 5 years has made it very clear that the Civil Conflict by no means actually ended, it was simply scabbed over,” he mentioned, including, “As appalled as I’m during the last 5 years, I’m additionally grateful that we’ve all been pressured to take a look at it.”
And the sophisticated: Harry Truman died when Clifton Truman Daniel was 15, and their relationship was not that completely different from every other grandfather and grandson. The Trumans didn’t have Secret Service safety till after President John Kennedy was assassinated, after which the brokers performed hen with the grandkids within the pool and secretly taught them to play billiards. “It was it was like having a bunch of closely armed uncles,” remembered Daniel. However one journey to Key West concerned a limousine, a aircraft journey, a personal jet and one other limousine. At one level, Daniel turned to his father: “Dad, are we getting richer?” “No,” his father replied. “We’re simply touring along with your grandfather.”
It wasn’t till after his grandfather died that he started to be taught extra concerning the man and the president. “The one distinction between me and every other child studying concerning the Truman administration was that I may go house and fact-check,” he mentioned. Daniel’s mom, the president’s solely youngster, was each fiercely protecting of her father and uninterested in being within the public eye. “We got here out of a restaurant one night time in New York, my father and my mom and I, and one other patron touched my mom on the shoulder and mentioned, ‘Excuse me, aren’t you Margaret Truman?’ And my mom smiled and mentioned, ‘No,’ and walked off. I assumed my father was going to get himself killed as a result of he mentioned, ‘No, no, no, she’s simply kidding. She actually is Margaret.’ “
That’s how Daniel ended up on the board of the Truman Library Institute. “It’s your flip,” his mom informed him.
He embraced his pedigree, working for the Harry S Truman Faculty in Chicago, lecturing on his grandfather and finally enjoying Truman within the one-man present originated by James Whitmore.
Throughout questions after the present, Daniel is usually requested about his grandfather’s determination to drop the atomic bombs on Japan. It was not one thing the 2 talked about when he was a child, however Daniel is fairly certain he would have heard the identical reply Truman mentioned publicly: He felt he needed to do it to forestall a floor conflict in Japan.
Daniel has been contacted by Japanese reporters on anniversaries of the bombing. A kind of interviews led to a gathering with survivors — which, in flip, led to his household touring to memorial ceremonies in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Survivors recorded testimony for the Truman Library; he spent 5 years speaking to New York college students about nuclear threats.
“All of us have this shared sense of preserving our ancestors’ legacy, however you can even try this in your personal approach,” mentioned Daniel of the descendants. “I went to Hiroshima and Nagasaki and labored with disarmament activists, which I feel my grandfather would have authorized of. He understood the hazard of these weapons. And I managed to do it with out maligning my grandfather, which is the job.”
Because the descendants gathered within the non-public membership’s ballroom, they pinned on identify tags that included their relationship to the president of their household tree, and later posed on risers for pictures.
That school scholar up there? Emory Whitman Gatchell, 20, a sixth-great granddaughter of James Monroe. When the historical past main shared her ties with the Founding Father to a good friend, he shot again, “Oh, so your cash is slave cash.” She mentioned, “No, no, no — that’s a giant misinterpretation. James Monroe died poor.” It’s a part of a dialog she’ll be having, a method or one other, for the remainder of her life.
With Roosevelt as president of the group, final weekend’s dinner was filled with references to his great-grandfather: In June, the descendants will collect at Teddy’s Lengthy Island house, Sagamore Hill — the primary of biennial scholarly presidential weekends everywhere in the nation. Close by Lengthy Island College is the group’s administrative headquarters, and a e book about TR and J.P. Morgan was certainly one of three finalists for the group’s first presidential management e book award.
The $10,000 prize, nonetheless, went to “Lincoln on the Verge: 13 Days to Washington” by Ted Widmer. “I feel we have to return to presidents,” Widmer informed the viewers, “to determine ourselves out.”
The night closed with — what else? — a choral rendition of “Hail to the Chief” (sure, there are lyrics) and “God Bless America.” There was, below all of the household historical past and drama, a deep properly of patriotism and hope on this room. The previous is prologue, but additionally the current — their current.
https://www.seattletimes.com/life/when-truman-is-your-grandpa-the-complicated-lives-of-presidential-descendants/?utm_source=RSS&utm_medium=Referral&utm_campaign=RSS_life | When Truman is your grandpa: The sophisticated lives of presidential descendants