This theory comes from reddit user siriusjakcwho believes that “Napoléon Dynamite” may take place in Purgatory. That sounds like a bold statement and they admitted as much in their original post, but they didn’t do it without giving some evidence to back it up.
First and foremost, they talk about how the characters dress as if they were from different periods. Napoléon fits the trend of the early 2000s, Pedro (Ramirez) has a country style of the 50s, and Deb (Majorino) looks like a kid from the 80s. Combine this with a sense of retro. Preston’s (lack of history, ruined landscape, etc.), and the theory begins to make sense. The post also speculates on how Napoleon and Pedro may have died and how the film hints at these events, including YouTube Link to Death Taco Podcast practice going deeper into things.
Reactions to this theory have been very positive, despite its bleak nature. Ralph-Hinkley replied, “I’ve mined it already, new headcanon confirmed,” and TortelliniSalad replied, “I love this movie, this is a scary twist.” To add to the conversation, they use a post that brings up the character of Uncle Rico (Jon Gries), whose entire characterization is that he has trapped himself in the past. “He seemed stuck, never getting over his old ‘high school version’,” they note, suggesting his personality factor could explain when he died and went to the Purgatory. prison.
As one might imagine, not everyone who shared their thoughts bought into what the original post had to offer. “I’d say it’s more likely that the filmmakers thought being trapped in a small town was like being trapped in Purgatory, and filled it with nonsense and made the setting weird. derived from that idea,” wrote wasporchidlouixse. Last Redditor ransub17 had similar thoughts, commenting, “The characters, style, and setting are all exactly what people who grew up in an unfamiliar place are.”
Is “Napoleon Dynamite” really a movie about lost souls trapped in Purgatory? Or does its presentation of Preston, Idaho, and its inhabitants only give us that impression? Regardless of the facts, if nothing else, theories like these are just fun to ponder.
https://www.looper.com/747220/the-dark-fan-theory-that-changes-everything-about-napoleon-dynamite/ The Dark Fan Theory Changed Everything About Napoleon Dynamite